Not A Drive-Thru: Car Plows Into Cheyenne Subway — A Fourth Time

A car plowed into a Cheyenne Subway store on Sunday, taking out a wall of windows and closing the sandwich shop. Employees say it's at least the fourth time it's been hit. “I guess they don’t know we don’t have a drive-thru," said one worker.

GJ
Greg Johnson

March 16, 20263 min read

Cheyenne
A car plowed into a Cheyenne Subway store on Sunday, taking out a wall of windows and closing the sandwich shop. It’s the fourth time the Subway at that busy intersection has been hit that employees can remember.
A car plowed into a Cheyenne Subway store on Sunday, taking out a wall of windows and closing the sandwich shop. It’s the fourth time the Subway at that busy intersection has been hit that employees can remember. (Adam Medina via Facebook)

CHEYENNE — Ladonnia Miller loves her job making sandwiches at the Subway outlet at the busy intersection of East Lincolnway and Converse Avenue. 

She’s bubbly, pleasant, and said she wants to be as accommodating as possible for customers. 

If she has one gripe, it’s the people who keep hitting the Subway building with their cars.

“The car ran fairly straight through the intersection and right into us,” she said Monday about the Sunday morning crash that put a gray four-door sedan through the northwest corner of the building.

It’s the fourth time that the Subway assistant manager can remember a car plowing into that corner of the building, which is mostly glass.

“We’ve had it happen three other times,” she said. “I don’t know why, but people just keep driving right into the building.

“I guess they don’t know we don’t have a drive-thru.”

  • A car plowed into a Cheyenne Subway store on Sunday, taking out a wall of windows and closing the sandwich shop. It’s the fourth time the Subway at that busy intersection has been hit that employees can remember.
    A car plowed into a Cheyenne Subway store on Sunday, taking out a wall of windows and closing the sandwich shop. It’s the fourth time the Subway at that busy intersection has been hit that employees can remember. (Greg Johnson, Cowboy State Daily)
  • A car plowed into a Cheyenne Subway store on Sunday, taking out a wall of windows and closing the sandwich shop. It’s the fourth time the Subway at that busy intersection has been hit that employees can remember.
    A car plowed into a Cheyenne Subway store on Sunday, taking out a wall of windows and closing the sandwich shop. It’s the fourth time the Subway at that busy intersection has been hit that employees can remember. (Greg Johnson, Cowboy State Daily)

Cuts Into Business

The crash happened early Sunday morning and kept the sandwich shop at 2301 E. Lincolnway closed for the day, Miller said, adding she was scheduled to work.

It reopened Monday with plywood covering the damage left by the car, which caused no injuries, she said.

Along with the windows, the car broke through a short brick wall that supports them and pushed the frame into the building several inches.

The crash will also impact business beyond Sunday’s closure, Miller said. 

The restaurant’s small dining room is closed until the damage can be fixed, she said. That means there are only four seats at two small tables available for in-store dining in front of the main counter.

“Obviously, it makes us a lot slower for business,” Miller said. “We’re getting more online orders, it seems. But yes, it’s impacted us, for sure.”

The timing of Sunday’s crash also makes it seem as though the building has a target on it, Miller said.

That’s because the front door had just been fixed the day before, after last week’s record-breaking windstorm ripped it off.

  • A car plowed into a Cheyenne Subway store on Sunday, taking out a wall of windows and closing the sandwich shop. It’s the fourth time the Subway at that busy intersection has been hit that employees can remember.
    A car plowed into a Cheyenne Subway store on Sunday, taking out a wall of windows and closing the sandwich shop. It’s the fourth time the Subway at that busy intersection has been hit that employees can remember. (Greg Johnson, Cowboy State Daily)
  • A car plowed into a Cheyenne Subway store on Sunday, taking out a wall of windows and closing the sandwich shop. It’s the fourth time the Subway at that busy intersection has been hit that employees can remember.
    A car plowed into a Cheyenne Subway store on Sunday, taking out a wall of windows and closing the sandwich shop. It’s the fourth time the Subway at that busy intersection has been hit that employees can remember. (Greg Johnson, Cowboy State Daily)

Déjà Vu

What caused the driver to veer into the Subway or if any citations were issued wasn’t known as of publication time as the Cheyenne Police Department was trying to get more information from the responding officers.

This story will be updated as that information is available.

In the meantime, work is already underway to fix the Subway, said Mike Smith with B&W Glass, who was at the store Monday morning taking measurements and examining the damage.

He said he felt a little bit of déjà vu because this isn’t the first time he’s fixed that corner of the sandwich shop after a car hit it.

“We’ve been here before — same corner,” Smith said. “Last time, it was here on this other side of the corner.”

Greg Johnson can be reached at greg@cowboystatedaily.com.

Authors

GJ

Greg Johnson

Managing Editor

Veteran Wyoming journalist Greg Johnson is managing editor for Cowboy State Daily.