Letter To Editor: A Closer Look at Speaker Sommers' Criticism Of Wyoming Freedom Caucus

Dear editor: "Speaker Sommers' voting record aligns 80.93% with Democrat Rep. Yin while only aligning 52.32% with the most conservative Republican, Rep. Bear. Does this make him a free thinker within the Republican Party or a Democrat in Republican clothing?"

June 11, 20233 min read

Collage Maker 11 Jun 2023 02 01 PM 391

Dear editor:

In light of recent remarks by Speaker Sommers questioning the political identity of the Freedom Caucus and emphasizing the importance of free-thinking within the Republican party, a closer look at the available voting data reveals a striking contrast between the Speaker's assertions and the evidence.

Data from Evidence-Based Wyoming provides a quantitative representation of the voting alignments of Wyoming legislators.

In this analysis, Rep. Yin (the minority floor leader) and Rep. Bear (the Wyoming Freedom Caucus leader) serve as Democratic and Republican benchmarks, respectively.

A comparison between the Frontier Republicans, identified as more liberal within the party, and the Freedom Caucus, representing the conservative wing, provides enlightening insights

Contrary to Speaker Sommers' assertions, Freedom Caucus members demonstrate a remarkable diversity of opinion in their voting records.

The standard deviation—a statistical measure of variability or variety in a data set—highlights this fact.

There is about five times more diversity in the Freedom Caucus compared to the Frontier Republicans when compared to Rep. Yin, and nearly 2.5 times more variety when compared to Rep. Bear's voting record.

Doug gerard 1 6 12 23

This begs the question, who are the real free thinkers in the Republican Party?

Interestingly, a caucus serves similar purposes to political parties as a whole.

They are established to organize and unify members around common goals and beliefs, promote specific ideologies, and navigate the legislative process more effectively.

They are crucial to a vibrant and functioning democratic system, allowing for various voices and perspectives within the larger political party.

This diversity of thought within a party allows for robust debate and reflection, resulting in more assertive policy.

The Freedom Caucus, with its demonstrated variety of opinions, is serving its purpose excellently within the Republican legislative delegation.

Turning back to Speaker Sommers' voting record, the data prompts us to consider: how Republican is he?

Sommers' voting record aligns 80.93% with Democrat Rep. Yin while only aligning 52.32% with the most conservative Republican, Rep. Bear.

Does this make him a free thinker within the Republican Party or a Democrat in Republican clothing?

Given the primary function of political parties and their internal caucuses—namely, the organization of legislators around common ideologies and policy goals—this question is worthy of consideration.

Also worth asking — If the Speaker is genuinely an independent thinker, as he claims, why isn't he an Independent?

At the end of the day, while political discourse and differing opinions within a party are signs of a healthy democracy, it's also essential that these assertions are backed by evidence.

The data indicate a different reality than the one painted by Speaker Sommers. The Freedom Caucus is far more diverse than the liberal Frontier Republicans.

Screen Shot 2023 06 11 at 2 06 29 PM

Sincerely,

Doug Gerard

Share this article