LARAMIE — About 30 local residents turned out Monday to the Albany County District Court to witness the arraignment of Stuart Schmidt, who is accused of ramming a wild horse with an ATV.
Schmidt, 60, is accused of charging at the wild horse with an ATV, leading to it being euthanized. He is facing one count of felony cruelty to wildlife and is out of jail on an unsecured bond.
Area landowner John Krenek was one of several attendees who told Cowboy State Daily he was infuriated by the allegations underpinning Schmidt’s charge.
Krenek said he consistently sees wild horses on his property and that they pose no threat that would require someone to ram one with a vehicle.
“They never do any damage, nothing,” Krenek said outside the courtroom. “So I don’t understand why this guy did it, and I just wanted to come down here and show that I’m not for letting this guy off.”
Arraignment
Schmidt attended his arraignment hearing via virtual link, accompanied by his attorney Grant Rogers.
Albany County District Court Judge Misha Westby explained to Schmidt his rights and the charge, which carries a maximum of two years in jail and a fine of up to $5,000 if he’s convicted.
Schmidt pleaded not guilty.
Westby assigned him a tentative trial date of March 2-4, 2026.
Aftermath
Many of the attendees in the courtroom then filed out into the hall as the judge moved on to the next arraignment.
Krenek said he was disgusted by the allegations made against Schmidt.
“We love horses, so we’re totally against somebody killing a horse like that,” he said. “We want to make sure people are thinking twice about killing animals like that. The horses aren’t doing any damage out there.”
Laramie resident Mel Duerksen described herself as an “animal lover, a horse lover,” and said she attended the arraignment to support friends who also wanted to be there but had to work Monday.
“It’s good for people to realize there are a lot of us in the community who care about animals,” she said. “We’re here to support the animals and hopefully improve our animal cruelty laws.”
Retired homeowner Wendy Baker called for Schmidt to face higher penalties given the severity of the accusations against him.
“When I heard about this case, I was sickened,” she said. “I had no choice but to come and support the horse that he killed."
Baker added that she believes maximum penalty for animal cruelty in Wyoming is too low and should be raised to become more severe.
“I think he should spend five years in prison and he should not only pay for all the expenses associated with putting the horse down,” she said. “I think he should have to pay somewhere around $15,000 to $20,000.”
The Accusations
Court documents obtained by Cowboy State Daily show Albany County Sheriff’s Deputy Ryder Seely responded to the sheriff’s office on Aug. 18 after receiving reports of a horse struck by an ATV.
Area resident Tammy Barnhart told the officer she witnessed Schmidt chase down a horse on an ATV at high speed until it fell to the ground. Those documents say Schmidt stopped to use his phone while the horse rose.
Schmidt then charged the horse again, the evidentiary affidavit says. The documents say the horse fell again and Schmidt struck it with the ATV.
The horse did not get back up after being struck, the documents claim.
The horse was then euthanized by Alex Sas-Jaworsky, whom the deputy wrote “owns all the wild horses in the Wild Horse Ranch (homeowners association)." The documents say the horse was struggling to breathe and could not get up in its final moments.
Schmidt told the officer he thought the horse was sick and didn’t want it to die on his property. He reported only traveling about two miles per hour on the vehicle while checking the horse’s legs and hooves.
Rogers told Cowboy State Daily the incident stems back to an ongoing land feud between Schmidt and Barnhart.
“Until June 2024, my client and the Barnharts were friends,” Rogers said. “That changed when my client opposed the Barnharts’ application to subdivide their… parcel to build another house.”
Animal Cruelty
The allegations come on the heels of a high-profile wolf torture case, which has enlivened Wyoming animal advocates.
Daniel man Cody Roberts in April used a snowmobile to run over a wolf and took it to a bar with a muzzle on, according to evidence and witness statements. Video of that incident shows the wolf weak and injured cowering in the corner as Roberts kisses it.
Roberts then killed the wolf and was subject to a $250 fine.
He was indicted on felony cruelty to animals in August and faces the same maximum penalty as Schmidt.
Jackson Walker can be reached at walker@cowboystatedaily.com.
